| Opponents | Date | Venue | Res | For | Against | Margin | ||
| Acanthus | H | 31/10/05 | D.5 | Melville | W | 13930 | 10500 | +14.04% |
| A | 26/10/06 | D.5 | Carlton | W | 14890 | 11970 | +10.89% | |
| Acolytes | A | 17/01/06 | D.5 | Melville | L | 10970 | 12500 | -6.52% |
| H | 20/02/07 | D.5 | Melville | W | 14040 | 10970 | +12.28% | |
| A | 03/02/09 | D.5 | Melville | W | 15640 | 13630 | +6..87% | |
| Athenians | A | 29/11/11 | D.4 | Melville | W | 13710 | 13080 | +2.35% |
| Berwick A | H | 17/11/10 | C.1 | Haddington | W | 15520 | 15140 | WIN |
| Berwick Bears | A | 14/11/05 | D.5 | Haddington | L | 10580 | 12460 | -8.16% |
| A | 26/10/07 | D.4 | Haddington | L | 13710 | 16750 | -9.98% | |
| A | 22/03/10 | D.4 | Haddington | L | 13010 | 13940 | -3.45% | |
| A | 18/10/10 | D.4 | Haddington | LD | 12320 | 12530 | -0.85% | |
| A | 05/10/11 | D.4 | Haddington | W | 15430 | 13800 | +5.58% | |
| Borderers | A | 22/01/08 | D.4 | Carfraemill | L | 12710 | 16570 | -13.18% |
| A | 26/01/10 | D.4 | Carfraemill | W | 13450 | 12710 | +2.83% | |
| A | 02/03/10 | C.QF | Carfraemill | W | 17680 | 16430 | WIN | |
| A | 15/02/11 | D.4 | Carfraemill | L | 11410 | 14360 | -11.38% | |
| A | 02/10/12 | D.3 | Carfraemill | W | 16420 | 13390 | +10.16% | |
| Brave Knaves | A | 10/02/04 | D.5 | Carfraemill | L | 14310 | 15450 | -3.83% |
| A | 18/11/08 | D.5 | Lauder (as Calchou) | WD | 12680 | 12500 | +0.17% | |
| Cantilever | A | 24/03/04 | D.5 | Carlton | LD | 22210 | 22630 | -0.94% |
| H | 14/03/05 | D.5 | Melville | L | 15300 | 16140 | -2.67% | |
| Carlton Camden | A | 14/02/08 | D.4 | Carlton | L | 9920 | 15070 | -20.61% |
| H | 03/11/09 | D.4 | Melville | W | 10370 | 9500 | +4.38% | |
| A | 17/01/11 | C.2 | Carlton | W | 17940 | 13650 | +9.81% | |
| H | 07/03/11 | D.4 | Carlton | L | 11660 | 13350 | -6.98% | |
| H | 11/01/12 | D.4 | Melville | W | 14430 | 10710 | +14.80% | |
| H | 06/01/12 | C.QF | Melville | L | 12050 | 13350 | ||
| Carlton Connection | H | 26/10/05 | C.1 | Mel. +5200 | L | 21120 | 21300 | -0.42% |
| Colinton Castle | A | 07/12/09 | D.4 | Tusitali Restaurant | W | 12910 | 11010 | +7.96% |
| H | 03/11/10 | D.4 | Melville | L | 13690 | 18510 | -14.97% | |
| A | 04/04/11 | C.SF | Tusitali Restaurant | W | 9780 | 9680 | +100 | |
| H | 27/02/13 | D.3 | Melville | L | 9770 | 11910 | -9.87% | |
| Comiston | H | 15/10/07 | D.4 | Melville | L | 9700 | 12030 | -10.72% |
| A | 09/02/10 | D.4 | Carlton | WD | 12260 | 12170 | +0.38% | |
| H | 08/02/11 | D.4 | Carlton | WD | 16140 | 15590 | +1.73% | |
| A | 07/12/11 | C.2 | Carl., -1200 | W | 18430 | 17940 | ||
| Diamonds | A | 15/03/06 | D.5 | Dunfermline | W | 16060 | 8320 | +31.75% |
| A | 15/11/06 | D.5 | Dunfermline | L | 10210 | 12760 | -11.10% | |
| H | 13/02/08 | D.4 | Melville | L | 7640 | 11300 | -19.32% | |
| H | 26/03/09 | D. 5 | Melville | W | 14010 | 12980 | +3.82% | |
| A | 23/01/12 | D. 4 | Dunfermline | W | 15040 | 11040 | +15.34% | |
| Dunbar | H | 12/11/08 | C.1 | Carlton | L | 18070 | 19470 | |
| A | 11/02/09 | D.5 | Dunbar | L | 10650 | 11500 | -3.84% | |
| H | 24/02/10 | D.4 | Melville | L | 10180 | 11340 | -5.39% | |
| A | 18/01/12 | D.4 | Dunbar | W | 12910 | 10120 | +12.11% | |
| Dunfermline “A” | H | 25/10/04 | C.1 | Mel. +5200 | W | 12050 | 10960 | |
| A | 15/02/07 | C.2 | Mel +2400 | L | 11280 | 17140 | ||
| Dunfermline “B” | A | 21/11/12 | D.3 | Dunfermline | L | 14940 | 16840 | -5.97% |
| Falcon | A | 12/02/13 | D.3 | Carlton | L | 13410 | 14270 | -3.11% |
| Fearless | H | 03/03/09 | D. 5 | Melville | W | 15990 | 8940 | +28.28% |
| Gosford | H | 06/12/12 | D.3 | Melville | L | 12520 | 13850 | -5.04% |
| Gullane | A | 04/12/03 | D.5 | Gullane | L | 12060 | 15610 | -12.83% |
| A | 10/12/07 | D.4 | Gullane | L | 12970 | 16710 | -12.60% | |
| H | 28/10/10 | D.4 | Gullane | L | 14170 | 15560 | -4.67% | A | 02/11/11 | D.4 | Gullane | W | 16050 | 13040 | +10.35% |
| Hawks | A | 03/02/04 | D.5 | Melville | W | 17370 | 14190 | +10.08% |
| H | 05/10/04 | D.5 | Melville | W | 14630 | 11640 | +11.38% | |
| A | 03/10/05 | D.5 | Melville | L | 14590 | 17130 | -8.00% | |
| H | 10/10/06 | D.5 | Melville | W | 17320 | 15200 | +6.52% | |
| A | 20/01/09 | D.5 | Melville | W | 12460 | 10730 | +7.46% | |
| Jethart | A | 25/11/03 | D.5 | Carfraemill | LD | 16000 | 16180 | -0.56% |
| H | 09/11/04 | D.5 | Carfraemill | W | 15220 | 11540 | +13.75% | |
| A | 26/01/06 | D.5 | Carfraemill | W | 14590 | 12060 | +9.49% | |
| H | 28/11/06 | D.5 | Carfraemill | W | 17430 | 11620 | +20.00% | |
| A | 14/10/08 | D.5 | Carfraemill | W | 15240 | 11360 | +14.59% | |
| Kelso | A | 24/11/09 | D. 4 | Lauder | W | 13180 | 12130 | +4.14% |
| A | 14/02/12 | D.4 | Lauder | W | 13890 | 12950 | +3.50% | |
| A | 06/11/12 | D.3 | Lauder | WD | 12280 | 11870 | +1.70% | |
| Linlithgow | H | 30/05/11 | MCF | Melville | L | 20150 | 22390 | -2240 |
| Livingston | A | 10/12/12 | D.3 | Livingston | L | 11060 | 15210 | -15.80% |
| Longniddry “B” | A | 13/11/03 | D.5 | Longniddry | WD | 11130 | 10770 | +1.64% |
| H | 14/04/05 | D.5 | Melville | L | 13450 | 15470 | -6.99% | |
| A | 21/03/07 | D.5 | Longniddry | W | 14940 | 11070 | +14.88% | |
| Longniddry Bees | A | 23/03/11 | D. 4 | Melville | LD | 17300 | 17900 | +1.70% |
| Mallard | H | 20/01/05 | D.5 | Melville | W | 14770 | 9640 | +21.02% |
| A | 22/02/06 | D.5 | Gullane | W | 17720 | 16470 | +3.66% | |
| H | 01/02/07 | D.5 | Melville | W | 16970 | 14290 | +8.57% | |
| A | 27/11/08 | D.5 | Gullane | W | 12960 | 12080 | +3.51% | |
| H | 09/11/09 | C.1 | Carlton -1200 | W | 12100 | 10670 | ||
| Marmion “A” | A | 21/10/04 | D.5 | N Berwick | L | 12520 | 14690 | -7.98% |
| H | 14/12/05 | D.5 | Melville | W | 14640 | 11480 | +12.1% | |
| H | 15/01/07 | D.5 | Melville | W | 10790 | 10120 | +3.12% | |
| A | 27/11/08 | D.5 | N. Berwick | W | 12510 | 11010 | +6.36% | |
| Marmion “B” | H | 09/01/13 | D.3 | Carlton | L | 10610 | 13350 | -11.88% |
| Merchiston | A | 17/02/11 | Cup QF | Melville | W | 19810 | 19160 | |
| Orion | H | 14/10/04 | D.5 | Melville | LD | 11220 | 11490 | -1.19% |
| A | 10/01/08 | D.4 | Melville | L | 11140 | 12680 | -6.47% | |
| H | 05/01/11 | D.4 | Melville | WD | 13410 | 12950 | +1.75% | |
| A | 08/02/12 | D.4 | Melville | W | 14530td> | 11410 | +12.03% | |
| Peebles | H | 01/03/04 | D.5 | Meadows | W | 12490 | 11250 | +5.22% |
| A | 22/02/05 | D.5 | Peebles | LD | 13420 | 13500 | -0.30% | |
| H | 29/11/05 | D.5 | Melville | W | 14630 | 11100 | +13.72% | |
| A | 26/02/08 | D.4 | Peebles | L | 11070 | 12510 | -6.11% | |
| H | 16/02/10 | D.4 | Melville | LD | 12890 | 13290 | -1.53% | |
| A | 23/11/10 | D.4 | Peebles | W | 10960 | 9810 | +5.5% | |
| H | 22/11/11 | D.4 | Melville | W | 14330 | 13610 | +2.58% | |
| Pied Pipers | A | 27/04/04 | BFC | Mel. +2400 | L | |||
| H | 18/04/05 | BFC | Mel. +3600 | W | 18000 | 15140 | ||
| A | XX/06/06 | BFC | Mel. +3600 | L | ||||
| H | 09/07/07 | BFC | Mel. +3600 | W | ||||
| A | 28/09/09 | BFC | Mel. +2400 | W | 17870 | 13380 | ||
| A | 12/10/10 | BFC | Car. +2400 | L | 12270 | 15490 | ||
| Randolph | A | 17/03/04 | D.5 | Carlton | L | 11690 | 13480 | -7.11% |
| H | 29/11/07 | D.4 | Melville | L | 9560 | 10850 | -6.32% | |
| A | 03/12/09 | D.4 | Carlton | LD | 14540 | 14930 | -1.32% | |
| Royal Scots “A” | H | 15/12/09 | C.2 | Carlton | W | walkover | ||
| A | 21/01/13 | D.3 | RS Club | LD | 16020 | 16560 | -1.66% | |
| Royal Scots “B” | A | 07/01/04 | C.2 | RSC. HC 0 | L | 10910 | 12040 | |
| H | 25/02/04 | D.5 | Meadows | W | 18480 | 16670 | +5.15% | |
| H | 25/01/05 | C.QF | Carl. HC 0 | L | 15510 | 16780 | ||
| A | 07/02/05 | D.5 | RS Club | L | 9830 | 10810 | -4.75% | |
| A | Nov 06 | C.2 | RSC. +1200 | L | 11730 | 13830 | ||
| Scramblers | A | 20/11/03 | C.1 | Melville | W | Defaulted | ||
| Skateraw | A | 14/11/12 | C.1 | Haddington | L | 12420 | 18960 | |
| Waverley | A | 13/12/04 | C.2 | Carl. +3600 | W | 14750 | 13540 | +4.28% |
| A | 23/03/10 | C.SF | Carl. +2400 | L | 17120 | 17290 | ||
| West Calder | A | 30/10/03 | D.5 | West Calder | L | 12050 | 13370 | -5.19% |
| H | 12/11/07 | D.4 | Melville | L | 9220 | 12340 | -14.47% | |
| A | 08/03/10 | D.4 | West Calder | L | 12770 | 14490 | -6.31% | |